DR PETER FIELDS • AI & IDEAS

THE AI NOTEBOOK / WHAT MATTERS AND WHY

What AI borrows when it answers

Dr Peter Fields •


On 3 November, Advocate General Szpunar advised the Court of Justice of the EU that an AI chatbot’s real-time retrieval and reuse of online press publications may in some circumstances infringe the related rights of press publishers. He proposed that the questions about training be declared inadmissible in this case. His opinion is advisory. In England, Getty’s appeal against Stability AI, heard on 11–12 November, raises a separate question about whether model weights can be an infringing copy for UK secondary infringement purposes.

The distinction matters for a reader who asks a chatbot what a newspaper reported. The answer may draw on an article fetched at that moment. That use raises questions about what was retrieved, how much was reused and on what terms, even if we know very little about the training data. In Knowledge, Search and Tools, I explain how retrieval changes the material available to the model. The two cases show why it matters to identify that step before asking what the law permits.

Sources CJEU summary of Advocate General Szpunar’s opinion in Case C-250/25 · Getty’s appeal skeleton, CA-2026-000007 · Stability AI’s appeal skeleton

Related Notebook articles Knowledge, Search and Tools · The Creative Divide

Retrospective commentary on the development of 12 November 2026.