DR PETER FIELDS • AI & IDEAS

THE AI NOTEBOOK / WHAT MATTERS AND WHY

Who makes the award when AI drafts it?

Dr Peter Fields •


The American Arbitration Association announced on 9 November that it was extending its AI Arbitrator to two-party commercial cases decided on documents alone. Under the process it describes, the system analyses the submissions and drafts an award. A human arbitrator reviews the draft, can revise it and issues the final award.

The division of labour looks straightforward on paper. In practice, a draft arrives with its own account of which facts matter and what they mean. In Can a Machine Judge?, I ask what makes the human decision independent. I would want to know whether the arbitrator has the time and the material needed to disagree with the draft, including to go back to a submission the system has misunderstood.

Sources American Arbitration Association announcement, 9 November

Related Notebook articles Can a Machine Judge?

Retrospective commentary on the development of 9 November 2026.