The Arizona Court of Appeals upheld Gabriel Horcasitas’s manslaughter conviction but set aside his sentence and ordered resentencing. At the sentencing hearing, the victim’s family had played a video in which an AI recreation of Christopher Pelkey delivered words written by his sister. The court concluded that relying on the video made the sentencing fundamentally unfair.
The family was entitled to speak about its loss. The difficulty was that the video gave a family member’s account the force of the victim’s own voice. An explanation of how it was made could tell the judge who wrote the words. It could do little to undo the impression created by watching Pelkey appear to say them. My article on deepfakes asks how we decide whether a scene is real. The Arizona case raises a different question. Even when everyone knows a scene is invented, how much weight should it carry?
Sources Arizona Court of Appeals, State v. Horcasitas, No. 1 CA-CR 25-0191, especially paragraphs 35–54
Related Notebook articles Deepfakes, Part 1 · Chatbots in the Courtroom
Retrospective commentary on the development of 30 September 2026.